Tend to when times are offered, they are given that have 24 hours of one’s month one really does not match with this date whilst within the genuine background. One such example takes place in Harry Potter together with Prisoner out-of Azkaban when Sybill Trelawney describes 16 October once the Friday, in the event sixteen Oct 1993 is a monday.
There are even contradictions into the books in this field. Such as for instance, from inside the Harry Potter in addition to Goblet regarding Fire, both step 1 September and you can dos September are offered since Mondays and you can, during the Harry Potter plus the Prisoner off Azkaban, Buckbeak’s trial is decided into 20 April, but careful parsing of one’s text message suggests that this may have occurred no afterwards than just March.
Along with, in Harry Potter and Cup away from Fire they state that Winners were chose towards Friday 31 October, but 29 October are a monday from inside the 1994.
From inside the chapter 7 off Quidditch Through the Years, they do say the earliest Quidditch Business Glass occured inside the 1473. In case your tournament was stored all few years, so it issues towards the declaration in Goblet regarding Fire that the 1994 Industry Mug try new 422nd. If the Quidditch Through the Years is useful, new 422nd Quidditch Industry Cup perform actually fall in the season 3161, in case Goblet of Fire excellent, the original Globe Cup was stored within the 306.
Historic dilemmas [ ]
As the series, with regards to the schedule derived from the Chamber regarding Gifts reference, is determined regarding the 1990s, the brand new series tend to seems as if it is place in brand new late nineties to help you middle-2000s, around concurrent for the guide of the books. For the Harry Potter and 1 / 2 of-Bloodstream Prince, Cornelius Fudge spends a masculine pronoun to mention on the « predecessor » of one’s Prime Minister of the United kingdom. According to significantly more than timeline, this should occur in the summertime out-of 1996, if the Perfect Minister are John Significant, whoever immediate predecessor is a lady (is why very first interviewing Fudge, the book states the fresh new election, but Significant was not first chose and only got more than after Thatcher resigned.
It’s possible, although not unrealistic, you to definitely Fudge might possibly be writing about a more distant predecessor, since the Thatcher took work environment in advance of Fudge allegedly became Minister for Magic. (Regardless of if it’s possible to envision a scenario where Fudge is actually delegated from the Minister to have Miracle in order to satisfy into the Best Minister while he, Fudge, was a student in a smaller sized place of work.) Additionally, the newest identity and reputation of the prime Minister depicted appears to way more closely meets compared to Tony Blair than regarding John Significant. A blog post on Every day Send cards you to definitely Rowling try intimate for the then-Chancellor of your Exchequer Gordon Brown (tend to considered a competition so you can Blair’s frontrunners of the Labour Group, just who succeeded your and you will turned Perfect Minister), which she might have been attempting to let you know Blair’s poor front. In the event the courses was basically place in connect having publication day from Philosopher’s Brick, next it enjoy manage occur in 2002 (shortly after Blair turned into Finest Minister).
But not, it absolutely was after stated that twenty two November are a friday, it was a student in 1994
A comparable disease pertains to Nicolas Flamel, who was simply mentioned as being 665 in the course of the newest first book, but Nicolas Flamel try a bona-fide historic contour and would not have reached you to age until 1996, in the go out the first publication is had written. The fresh new rebuttal because of it is the fact that the date the « real » Nicolas Flamel was born doesn’t keep in touch with the fresh Nicolas Flamel away from Harry Potter.
A new condition can be found of Rubeus Hagrid’s tenure just like the Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It is designed regarding the series that Hagrid was given one reputation within a few years off their expulsion away from college or university inside the 1942. But in that world of Harry Potter as well as the Goblet out of Flames, Molly Weasley reminisces from the Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper apparently overlap with Molly’s decades at school, it seems unlikely you to definitely she recalls a past gamekeeper. not, it will be possible you to Hagrid american men meeting bulgarian women don’t getting good gamekeeper immediately immediately after becoming expelled, but alternatively become just like the Ogg’s secretary. This might be plausible once the when Harry believes that he will become expelled having traveling to the broomstick versus permission in his first year, he secret if the he would be permitted to stick to since Hagrid’s assistant.